Bay kickers come up just short in sectional final thriller
Team just misses first state berth since 2003
Whitefish Bay - Not meaning to sound arrogant or dismissive of the very deep sectionals that his team has played in, Brookfield East boys soccer coach Herbie Dundun still said the WIAA State Tournament berths the Spartans earned in 2010 and 2011 were "almost givens."
Not so this year. East had huge graduation losses, and furthermore, it lost five more potential starters to the newly founded soccer academy in the area.
So on Saturday at Brookfield Central, after the Spartans earned their third state trip in a row to Uihlein Park with a heart-stopping, 3-2 overtime shootout WIAA sectional final victory over a persistent Whitefish Bay team, a relieved Dundun said this state slot feels much different from the others.
"We were fishing here and there, trying to put the pieces together," he said. "The chemistry was always something a little different, something we were always working on."
"It was very much on the edge at times. It's very satisfying to have done this, but it feels very patched together. We had to fill the gaps as we went along."
As a result, the Spartans (14-7-3) will take on Kimberly in a 5 p.m. Thursday WIAA Division 1 state quarterfinal game at Uihlein Soccer Park in Milwaukee.
For the "patched-together" East players, this is a dream come true, nothing that feels like a given at all.
"It's an unbelievable feeling, it's like you're on top of the world," said sophomore goalie Drew Johnson, who made a critical stop of Bay's third penalty kick and who also saved the game for East with just seconds to go in the first overtime session, when he tipped a spectacular point blank bicycle kick shot by the Blue Dukes' Jack Menard just over the top of the crossbar.
"It's our third trip in a row, but my first and I wouldn't want to go with any other team," he added.
"It takes on a whole new meaning being in my final year," said senior forward and tri-captain John Orgovan, who gave East it's first lead at 1-0 in the 28th minute off a close-in rebound of a shot by teammate Trenton Daniels that had ricocheted off the left post.
In a game dominated by fouls and great set piece offense, a desperate Bay team pressed hard in the final five minutes of regulation, trailing 2-1.
The Blue Dukes (14-5-3) earned a couple of corner kicks in that time but could make nothing of them, but after an East clear they got the ball back and senior defender T.J. Schmid made a great long feed ahead to a racing senior defender Jake Taylor, who one-touched it perfectly past Johnson for the tying goal at the 77:56 mark.
It was as if anyone was thinking that they had had enough soccer for the evening after the regulation whistle blew, they should have been listening to one of the linesman who mopped his brow and grabbed a drink just before the start of the first overtime session.
"Who wants to go home now," he said. "It's such a great game."
"It was a right fast finish," said Blue Duke coach Andy Lee of Taylor's effort. "I thought that he (Taylor) was very composed on that play."
And Lee had the right to think that as he said later, that "we carried forward some confidence after the equalizer."
There was more excitement in the first overtime as East got the first two pretty good tries before the closing dramatics of the Bay bicycle kick.
In the second overtime session, Dundun struggled to maintain his team's focus. "Call out your numbers (your marks)," he shouted to the team as the period started. "This is no time to rest."
East pressed hard, but Bay goalie Alex Witteman made three solid saves to keep the Spartans from the game-winner and to force the penalty kick shootout.
The Spartans were up 3-2 in the penalty kick phase when Johnson made his critical save. East senior midfielder Ryan Toy, who had given East a 2-0 lead at the 41:45 mark with an assist from Orgovan, then pounded home his shot to make it 4-2.
And when the subsequent Blue Dukes player bounced his shot off the side post, the Spartans spilled onto the field to celebrate.
"It was always a tight thing and it could have been our game in overtime," Lee said. "It was unfortunate it came down to penalty kicks."
Before his dramatic tying goal late in regulation, Taylor had pulled Bay to within 2-1 at the 45:25 mark as he headed in a perfect free kick from the left side courtesy of senior forward Joey Davey.
Exciting elements like that just kept this game a fan favorite throughout the evening.
"There was a lot there if you were a neutral (fan). A good game," Lee said.
Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.
Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter Get the Newsletter!
- Whitefish Bay boys basketball team rallies past Nicolet, 79-74
- Whitefish Bay boys basketball team asserts it will, beats Homestead
- After break, Whitefish Bay gymnasts return to winning ways
- Whitefish Bay boys basketball team battles back to beat West Allis Central
- Jake Wolter ready for Whitefish Bay football job
- Germantown boys basketball team slips by Whitefish Bay, 92-88, in OT
- Tietjen remembered by many in powerful tribute
- Whitefish Bay football team honored Tietjen with NSC title
- Football: Friends remember Whitefish Bay football coach Jim Tietjen, who died after battle with brain cancer (2)
- Young Whitefish Bay swimmers get payoff with six state entries